Skip to main content

U. S. Supreme Court decision could signal shift in views on separation of church and state, a WVU legal expert says

No thumbnail image for this story
 John Taylor, Jackson Kelly Professor at the WVU College of Law
Download full-size

Taxpayer-funded repairs of a church-owned preschool playground may sound like a small matter, but to one West Virginia University legal expert, the U. S. Supreme Court decision that allows the funding in Missouri signals a shift in how the high court views separation of church and state.

John Taylor
Jackson Kelly Professor
WVU College of Law

“Prior to the 1980s, the Supreme Court read the federal Establishment Clause in the First Amendment to mean that states could not fund church-affiliated institutions because of separation of church and state. The Court’s recent decision in Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia, Inc. vs. Comer effectively requires Missouri to fund church preschools on the same terms as other preschools. The decision could herald a significant shift in the way the court reads the Establishment Clause, pointing toward a rule that religious institutions must always (or nearly always) be included in general state funding programs. If adopted, such a rule would flip the Court’s reading of the Religion Clauses 180 degrees from what it was four decades ago.”

Contact information:
304.293.8180 (office)
304.376.3539 (cell)

West Virginia University experts can provide commentary, insights and opinions on various news topics. Search for and expert by name, title, area of expertise, or college/school/department in the Experts Database at WVUToday.